Note: Perhaps too much detail … Sorry.
So I have replaced the headlight covers on the 1996 Tahoe with the inexpensive pair (<$50 including Shipping) purchased from a vendor on Amazon. Here are my thoughts:
Description: The pair came with headlight covers, backing plate, bulbs and electrical connectors.
Quality: The set is lighter in weight than stock and seem to be of lesser quality though they are not so bad as to be alarming. The lenses are crystal clear but perhaps thinner than stock. The unit is DOT approved. The left side cover would not fit into the stock backing plate (more later).
Replacement: I thought this would be a piece of cake replacement. I watched this video (
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UfsFGfNcPY0) and figured that I could mount the new headlight covers on the old backing plate and be done in 15 minutes. I removed the 5mm studs, took out the old cover, moved the connectors and bulbs into the new unit. However, the drivers side cover would not mount to the backing plate (I think due to a difference in the flange that fits into a backing plate slot). So I had to go the long route of replacing the backing plates which required removal of the parking lamps and grill.
Grill Removal: I removed the parking lamps using a drill with a Phillips bit (4 screws per lamp), and removed the bulbs. Then I removed 7 of the 10 7mm screws that hold the grill in place. Three screws, however, were nearly impossible for me to remove with the tools I was using (1/4†drive ratchet and socket). These were located near bumper level on the far left and right (under the parking lamps) and one under the bow tie. With the help of a pair of nine year-olds (and keeping the cursing under control) I did succeed. More later.
Backing Plate Replacement: Each plate has 4 10mm screws … easy off and on.
Cover Mounting: Again, very easy, just reinsert the 5mm studs, two per side.
Grill Replacement: I was dreading the grill replacement but after inspecting the bottom of the grill I found the that the 3 difficult screw from removal are actually part of a grill clip-on system. I unclipped the body color bottom portion of the grill, easily reinstalled with 5 screws, then push fit the bottom of the grill into the clips, using a rubber mallet for some extra force, then refit the remain screws.
Question for the group: What is the proper method for removing the grill? Should I have tried to unclip the bottom of the grill from the body color portion?
Summary: The new headlight covers are inexpensive but I would call them an “OK value†and not “cheap†(i.e. I am not worried about them failing). I did use the stock light bulbs and connectors and put the bulbs and connectors from the kit in storage. Installation should have taken just a few minutes but because one of the covers did not match the backing plate I had to remove the grill. Perhaps I would have paid some extra money for covers that fit the backing plates (note that the video maker sells pairs for $60 or so). Grill removal was a knuckle-banger (might be a wrong method on my part) but otherwise this is a simple job and should take less time than buffing out the lenses.